Is Avalara MyLodgeTax Worth It?
The honest take — no sales pitch, no "it depends" cop-out. Who it fits, who should skip it.
Verdict
It depends
Worth it if your portfolio spans enough jurisdictions that DIY compliance is a real liability — overkill for simple setups.
Realistic cost: ~$135/mo for 5 listings plus $1,495 one-time setup
Worth it if you…
- You manage 5+ properties across multiple tax jurisdictions
- You've received or worry about tax compliance notices or penalties
- You'd rather pay a predictable monthly fee than hire a tax specialist
- You're scaling into new markets and need registration handled for you
Skip it if you…
- You have 1–4 properties in a single jurisdiction — the math doesn't work
- Your OTA platforms already collect and remit all applicable taxes
- You have an accountant who handles lodging tax filings as part of existing services
- You need broader compliance beyond lodging taxes (1099s, zoning, HOA)
What to try instead
For DIY tax calculation, consider Avalara's AvaTax API or a local CPA familiar with STR tax obligations.
See all Avalara MyLodgeTax alternatives →Is Avalara MyLodgeTax right for you?
Honest per-segment take. Click any card for the full breakdown.
1–5 listings
Small portfolios
Per-property costs are prohibitive at 1–4 listings — $27/month each plus $299 setup per property.
Read full take →
5–20 listings
Mid-sized portfolios
The sweet spot — enough properties to justify per-unit costs, and compliance complexity rises fast with multi-jurisdiction exposure.
Read full take →
20–100 listings
Large portfolios
Built for scale — supports portfolios up to 40,000+ properties with volume-based commercial pricing.
Read full take →
Airbnb primary
Airbnb-first hosts
Useful if you operate in jurisdictions where Airbnb doesn't fully handle tax collection, but potentially redundant where they do.
Read full take →
Vrbo primary
Vrbo-first hosts
Similar value as for Airbnb-focused hosts — helpful where platform tax collection falls short.
Read full take →
3+ channels
Multi-channel operators
Multi-channel operators face the most complex tax obligations — a centralized compliance service pays for itself in avoided penalties.
Read full take →
Ready to try Avalara MyLodgeTax?
From $27/listing • No free trial
Build your stack
See whether Avalara MyLodgeTax fits your actual STR stack
Worth-it pages answer one vendor question. The stack-builder turns that into a full setup order across operations, pricing, guest messaging, and direct booking.